Mobiledia: Cell Phones
Google
Web Mobiledia.com

Find us on Facebook We're on Facebook! Join our Group or take our fun What's Your Cell Phone? Quiz and get matched with the perfect cell phones for your lifestyle.
 

Home > Cell Phone Forums > Carriers Talk > T-Mobile Talk > T-mobile, is it as good as Cingular on a national scale?

T-mobile, is it as good as Cingular on a national scale?

Page 3 of 5
Reply to topic
Prev  1, 2, 3, 4, 5  Next
Author Message

Stormalert
3D Hologram Enthusiast
Posts: 15

Phone Model:
Samsung u740

Service Provider:
$0.02c Wireless
Reply with quote Report post to Moderator
Mon Mar 13, 2006 8:46 pm 
I used to have At&t (now cingular). when att merged and stuff, all their computer stuff got messed up. Their customer service was also horrible! The coverage around my house was not that good, and it never got a 100% signal. I know T-mo customers who have a great signal. Actually I have to say that Verizon's the best though (except for their motorolas).
Advertisement
 

man1234
Radiation Shield Addict
Posts: 208

Phone Model:
Sanyo Katana II

Service Provider:
Sprint
Reply with quote Report post to Moderator
Mon Mar 13, 2006 8:55 pm 
Stormalert wrote:
I used to have At&t (now cingular). when att merged and stuff, all their computer stuff got messed up. Their customer service was also horrible! The coverage around my house was not that good, and it never got a 100% signal. I know T-mo customers who have a great signal. Actually I have to say that Verizon's the best though (except for their motorolas).


i completely agree with you... verizon does have the best service nation wide and then i like tmobiles 2nd best ... i currently have cingular and am switching to tmobile in like 10 days icon_lol.gif icon_biggrin.gif icon_w00t.gif today i couldnt make a call with 3 bars ... SO SADDD CINGULAR, SOO SAD

Damobius
Antenna Booster Novice
Posts: 7

Phone Model:
Samsung SGH-S300

Service Provider:
T-Mobile
Reply with quote Report post to Moderator
Thu Mar 16, 2006 1:45 pm 
I've had no trouble so far with T-Mobile's network, or at least their roaming partners. Of course that may change if they lose roaming contracts.

My issue has been with T-Mobile customer service. All was good as long as they were providing me information that would assist me in stepping into another T-Mobile marketing channel (logging on to their website), but the minute that I asked for something that didn't allow them another way to get their hooks into my wallet, they shut down.

See http://forums.mobiledia.com/viewtopic.php?p=166150#166150 for the full story. I probably will be checking out Verizon when my contract expires. I may not leave T-Mobile, but I've seen this pattern of customer service before, and it generally leads to a bad situation. It all depends on what Verizon has to offer when my contract expires in December...
iowa
Flashing Antenna Designer
Posts: 1273

Phone Model:
Sanyo Katana Deluxe\LG Rumor\Palm Centro

Service Provider:
Sprint~MyPlan (2 Lines 1000 Min, Free Roaming,Free Internet, Free Text, Free Pick 5, Free Mobile 2 Mobile, 25% Loyalty Discount, Free Nights & Weekends@5PM, 7$ Recurring Credit.) 80 Bucks.
Reply with quote Report post to Moderator
Fri Mar 17, 2006 4:48 am 
elmo01 wrote:
iowa wrote:
T Mobile And Cingular Both Suck. Gsm Carriers In General Suck. Cdma Is The Way To Go.


thank you for your input... CDMA works well in North America... try using your CDMA phone in Europe or Asia... let me know how it works out....



cdma Is A Much Better Technology Than Gsm And Can Handle More Calls Per Tower Than Gsm, And Also Penetrates Buildings Better Than Gsm. I'm An American And Proud Of It. Not My Fault Europe And Asia Are Primitive. Oh Yeah. Sprint Carries A Gsm And Cdma Hybrid Phone Just For Those Trips icon_smile.gif And It's Free To Borrow. Or You Can Just Buy It. But I Ain't Going Overseas Any Time Soon , So I'll Just Stick With The Superior Cdma Technology. Oh And As For Roaming Charges? No Such Thing Any More. Don't Even Get Overage Charges! Back In The Day, Who Didn't Charge For Roaming?

elmo01
Moderator
Posts: 2198

Phone Model:
Samsung SPH-M510

Service Provider:
Bell Canada
Reply with quote Report post to Moderator
Fri Mar 17, 2006 11:06 am 
iowa wrote:
elmo01 wrote:
iowa wrote:
T Mobile And Cingular Both Suck. Gsm Carriers In General Suck. Cdma Is The Way To Go.


thank you for your input... CDMA works well in North America... try using your CDMA phone in Europe or Asia... let me know how it works out....



cdma Is A Much Better Technology Than Gsm And Can Handle More Calls Per Tower Than Gsm, And Also Penetrates Buildings Better Than Gsm. I'm An American And Proud Of It. Not My Fault Europe And Asia Are Primitive. Oh Yeah. Sprint Carries A Gsm And Cdma Hybrid Phone Just For Those Trips icon_smile.gif And It's Free To Borrow. Or You Can Just Buy It. But I Ain't Going Overseas Any Time Soon , So I'll Just Stick With The Superior Cdma Technology. Oh And As For Roaming Charges? No Such Thing Any More. Don't Even Get Overage Charges! Back In The Day, Who Didn't Charge For Roaming?


your logic is "primitive" at best
holly
Antenna Booster Novice
Posts: 7

Phone Model:
v360

Service Provider:
tmo
Reply with quote Report post to Moderator
Fri Mar 17, 2006 8:38 pm 
[/quote]I do believe that Tmob uses a third party vendor for at least some of its tech support and customer care[/quote]

No we do not and 3rd party vendors but, we do have tmo authorized dealers who are not tmo owned but do offer our service i can say that they can make their own prices on phns but cannot change the prices of the rate plans
iowa
Flashing Antenna Designer
Posts: 1273

Phone Model:
Sanyo Katana Deluxe\LG Rumor\Palm Centro

Service Provider:
Sprint~MyPlan (2 Lines 1000 Min, Free Roaming,Free Internet, Free Text, Free Pick 5, Free Mobile 2 Mobile, 25% Loyalty Discount, Free Nights & Weekends@5PM, 7$ Recurring Credit.) 80 Bucks.
Reply with quote Report post to Moderator
Sat Mar 18, 2006 3:13 am 
Fyi My Logic Is Based On Pure Fact. That Is The Very Essence Of Logic And You Can't Get Much More Logical Than That. To Think So Would Be, Well, Illogical. So Go Ahead And Explain Your "logic " And Let's See If It Holds Any Water.

Sir_GoAtaLoT
Faceplate Artist
Posts: 406

Phone Model:
BlackBerry 8100 Pearl

Service Provider:
Rogers
Reply with quote Report post to Moderator
Sat Mar 18, 2006 4:03 pm 
funny GSM is the new and it will soon be every were in the USA
rambo47
Antenna Booster Novice
Posts: 6

Phone Model:
SE K790i

Service Provider:
T-Mobile
Reply with quote Report post to Moderator
Sat Mar 25, 2006 6:28 pm 
I'm using T-Mobile here in the wilds of northern New Jersey and I love it. The wife has Verizon, and while her signal strength is maybe 5 - 10% better than mine, it's not enought to make a difference. What really makes the difference in favor of TMO is their excellent customer service. Couple that with the fact that I never get a call dropped out here or in New York City (work) and it's a winner.

My primary phone is the Treo 650 so having an unlocked GSM phone is huge considering how much I travel overseas.

Cingularity
3D Hologram Enthusiast
Posts: 22

Phone Model:
SonyEricsson S710a

Service Provider:
The Largest One
Reply with quote Report post to Moderator
Sun Mar 26, 2006 3:56 am 
Damobius wrote:
I just left Cingular after 5 years, and have vowed to never return, due to customer service issues. I just signed up with T-Mobile, and so far am VERY pleased with them.

Directly to your point, I am using a Samsung SGH-S300 that for some reason cannot see the T-Mobile network (I've posted here asking if anyone knows why), but I can still use the Cingular and AT&T (and presumably other) networks just fine. The Motorola phone that T-Mobile sent me seems to get fine reception as well on the T-Mobile networks that I've tried it with (the Motorola can see Cingular's network just fine).

Bottom line is, I doubt you'd see much difference, since T-Mobile can use Cingular's networks as well, and if you have a Nationwide plan there will be no roaming charges. My personal recommendation though sides with T-Mobile, though not for the reason that you're asking about here.



Damobius,

It could be the frequency at which T-Mobile is transmitting in the area and perhaps the phone is not able to recognize that frequency. You could check the specs of the phone to see which ones the phone operates on. Cingular uses both US frequencies of 850 & 1900 Mhz but not necessarily both in the same market. I'm not sure if T-mobile has the license for both 850 & 1900 Mhz frequencies.

As for T-mobile's use of the Cingular network, yes and no. I have a friend of mine with T-mobile, but his phone was inoperable in my hometown where my phone has perfect signal. T-mobile's coverage is based on the roaming agreements with Cingular. That's why their coverage is not as broad as Cingular's coverage.
Reply to topic Prev  1, 2, 3, 4, 5  Next
Page 3 of 5

Similar Topics


 Topic   Posts 
No new posts T-Mobile Firmware for Nokia 3595 6
No new posts T-Mobile G1 3G plan's cost? 10
No new posts T-Mobile 3G expansion plans? 6
No new posts Motorola ACTV Rugged Clamshell Released for T-Mobile 5
No new posts T-Mobile G1 with Google Android OS to Launch Oct. 22 5
No new posts Replacing defective T-Mobile Sidekick Slide 5
No new posts Why T-Mobile sucks 16
No new posts T-Mobile 3G works in suburbs? 6
No new posts T-Mobile 3G for iPhone 2G? 9
No new posts Verizon clamshell with long battery, QWERTY, good receiver? 6


New T-Mobile Cell Phones


Samsung Gravity (T459)Samsung Behold (T919)Nokia 1680 ClassicSamsung T109Motorola ACTV (W450)
Samsung Gravity (T459) Samsung Behold (T919) Nokia 1680 Classic Samsung T109 Motorola ACTV (W450)
More T-Mobile Phones >


Home > Cell Phone Forums > Carriers Talk > T-Mobile Talk > T-mobile, is it as good as Cingular on a national scale?


Find Free Phones
Free Cell Phones Free Cell Phones
Free Camera Phones Free Camera Phones
Free Smartphones Free Smartphones

Carriers Talk

AT&T Talk (Cingular) AT&T Talk (Cingular)
Sprint Nextel Talk Sprint Nextel Talk
T-Mobile Talk T-Mobile Talk
Verizon Wireless Talk Verizon Wireless Talk
CSR Talk CSR Talk

Manufacturers Talk

Apple Talk Apple Talk
LG Talk LG Talk
Motorola Talk Motorola Talk
Nokia Talk Nokia Talk
Samsung Talk Samsung Talk
Sony Ericsson Talk Sony Ericsson Talk
Smartphone / PDA Talk Smartphone / PDA Talk

Mobiledia Community

The Lounge The Lounge
News Headlines News Headlines
The Rules The Rules
Meet the Team Meet the Team
Forum Archive Forum Archive


Google
Web Mobiledia.com

©2002-2008 Mobiledia Corp. A Cell Phone Resource Site. All Rights Reserved. Terms of Use | Privacy Policy