Mobiledia: Cell Phones
Google
Web Mobiledia.com

Find us on Facebook We're on Facebook! Join our Group or take our fun What's Your Cell Phone? Quiz and get matched with the perfect cell phones for your lifestyle.
 

Home > Cell Phone Forums > Carriers Talk > Sprint Nextel Talk > Sprint or T-Mobile?

Sprint or T-Mobile?

Page 1 of 4
Reply to topic
1, 2, 3, 4  Next
Author Message
Johanna
Antenna Booster Novice
Posts: 3
Reply with quote Report post to Moderator
Wed Jul 25, 2007 6:26 pm 
I'm down to my final two carriers--sprint and t-mobile--and I need to choose one. Here's my list of pros and cons:

Sprint:
Pros:
-I can get a 15% discount off a monthly plan through my school
-nights and weekends begin at 7pm
-coverage seems more than adequate for the two most important areas I'll be
Cons:
-I've heard bad things about their customer service
-I've heard it takes a long time for them to apply a discount that you might get through work or school
-only 450 shared minutes for the family plan I'm looking at

T-Mobile
Pros:
-I've heard their customer service is good (or at least better than sprint)
-1000 minutes for the same price as the sprint family plan
-I may be able to get a veteran discount (I think they offer one--anyone know more?)

Cons:
-I don't know if their coverage will work for sure in the two areas I need
-a 14-day trial period instead of the 30-day trial period sprint has

What do you guys think?
Advertisement
 

man1234
Radiation Shield Addict
Posts: 208

Phone Model:
Sanyo Katana II

Service Provider:
Sprint
Reply with quote Report post to Moderator
Thu Jul 26, 2007 2:01 pm 
I have actually had both of the companies. But i still have tmobile. I'd say sprint is better. If you are going to be a buildings throughout your day, sprint is better for you because CDMA (sprints technology) generates signal better through buildings than GSM ( tmobile's technology) does. I like to talk on the phone, so I'd prefer nights at 7 than 9. Also my tmobile phone has a lousy internal antenna. If i put my hand over the top of the phone at any time, my signal drops 1 -2 to even 3 bars. Not good. Especially becuase this happens more often when im on a call, making a dropped call easier to get. I did not have that problem with sprint, having had an internal antenna on my sprint phone as well. So for those reasons, I say you should get sprint

good luck
Barciur
Radiation Shield Addict
Posts: 245

Phone Model:
Nokia 5300

Service Provider:
T-Mobile USA/Plus GSM
Reply with quote Report post to Moderator
Thu Jul 26, 2007 2:21 pm 
You mean T-mobile towers are worse then Sprint towers. Because in Europe there is NO problem in buildings. And there is only GSM.
mbb102488
Antenna Booster Novice
Posts: 2
Reply with quote Report post to Moderator
Sun Jul 29, 2007 11:35 am 
That is true. But here in the United States we have both. I have T-Mobile because of my parents and now I have a Sprint/Nextel phone because sprint has much better coverage in my area than T-Mobile. As far as value and that goes, T-Mobile is good if you want basic service. If you want to have good phone service I'd go with Sprint. The discount takes about 2 billing cycles to appear and their customer service isn't all that bad. I personally don't like T-Mobile because they always try to make me buy a new phone everytime something little happens to it :-/

McGirk
Flashing Antenna Designer
Posts: 2412

Phone Model:
AX380 Wave

Service Provider:
Alltel
Reply with quote Report post to Moderator
Sat Aug 04, 2007 10:26 am 
Lower frequencies penetrate buildings better. It's not a matter of GSM vs. CDMA. TMobile (in the US at least) only use the 1900mhz frequency, whereas Sprint uses both the 1900 and 800 mhz frequencies. Because of this Sprint also has better coverage in more rural areas. From what I've encountered TMobile offers more minutes for your dollar then any of the other companies, but that must largely be due to the fact that they are compensating for having the weakest coverage of all the top companies. There are smaller companies then TMobile, with dramatically better coverage. Alltel being one of those.
DonDon
Antenna Booster Novice
Posts: 1
Reply with quote Report post to Moderator
Mon Oct 08, 2007 4:06 pm 
Every person i know that has sprint, has horrible reception. also, when you supposedly don't have reception, you're roaming, and therefore paying more!
Barciur
Radiation Shield Addict
Posts: 245

Phone Model:
Nokia 5300

Service Provider:
T-Mobile USA/Plus GSM
Reply with quote Report post to Moderator
Tue Oct 09, 2007 6:37 am 
So it's better to be roaming then not have reception, don't you think?

McGirk
Flashing Antenna Designer
Posts: 2412

Phone Model:
AX380 Wave

Service Provider:
Alltel
Reply with quote Report post to Moderator
Wed Oct 10, 2007 4:08 pm 
Sprint doesn't charge anything for roaming as long as you use more minutes off of their towers then their roaming partners. And Coverage has as much to do geographically as anything. In one area it may work great and in another not so much. Always ask independant dealers who sell more then one which company they would go with. An independant company shouldn't feel the need to stick with one company or another, so are more likely (not totally, but more at least) to be honest with you.

man1234
Radiation Shield Addict
Posts: 208

Phone Model:
Sanyo Katana II

Service Provider:
Sprint
Reply with quote Report post to Moderator
Wed Oct 10, 2007 10:27 pm 
DonDon wrote:
Every person i know that has sprint, has horrible reception. also, when you supposedly don't have reception, you're roaming, and therefore paying more!


sprint hasnt charged for roaming in over a year now . close to 2 years. So maybe your friends are on an older plan. also sprint has alot better reception than tmobile. i have been in plenty of areas around the US, so i have the right to attempt that statement. and if sprints reception is "horrible" then i cant even begin to see how people would describe tmobile's reception icon_surprised.gif icon_squint.gif
iowa
Flashing Antenna Designer
Posts: 1282

Phone Model:
Sanyo Katana Deluxe\LG Rumor\Palm Centro

Service Provider:
Sprint~MyPlan (2 Lines 1000 Min, Free Roaming,Free Internet, Free Text, Free Pick 5, Free Mobile 2 Mobile, 25% Loyalty Discount, Free Nights & Weekends@5PM, 7$ Recurring Credit.) 80 Bucks.
Reply with quote Report post to Moderator
Thu Feb 28, 2008 9:40 pm 
Sprint the best coverage in america--- lol just check coverage maps.
Reply to topic 1, 2, 3, 4  Next
Page 1 of 4

Similar Topics


 Topic   Posts 
No new posts Why T-mobile really is the worst service ever! 5
No new posts need a List of Sprint Phones w/ wifi 7
No new posts Sprint-NO RESPECT 8
No new posts T-Mobile Firmware for Nokia 3595 6
No new posts HTC Touch Pro Launches for Sprint 5
No new posts T-Mobile G1 3G plan's cost? 10
No new posts Sprint upgrade policy 26
No new posts I hate Sprint at the moment 12
No new posts T-Mobile 3G expansion plans? 6
No new posts Motorola ACTV Rugged Clamshell Released for T-Mobile 5


New Sprint Cell Phones


Sanyo Katana Eclipse XSamsung Rant (M540)Samsung Highnote (M630)LG Lotus (LX600)HTC Touch Pro
Sanyo Katana Eclipse X Samsung Rant (M540) Samsung Highnote (M630) LG Lotus (LX600) HTC Touch Pro
More Sprint Phones >


Home > Cell Phone Forums > Carriers Talk > Sprint Nextel Talk > Sprint or T-Mobile?


Find Free Phones
Free Cell Phones Free Cell Phones
Free Camera Phones Free Camera Phones
Free Smartphones Free Smartphones

Carriers Talk

AT&T Talk (Cingular) AT&T Talk (Cingular)
Sprint Nextel Talk Sprint Nextel Talk
T-Mobile Talk T-Mobile Talk
Verizon Wireless Talk Verizon Wireless Talk
CSR Talk CSR Talk

Manufacturers Talk

Apple Talk Apple Talk
LG Talk LG Talk
Motorola Talk Motorola Talk
Nokia Talk Nokia Talk
Samsung Talk Samsung Talk
Sony Ericsson Talk Sony Ericsson Talk
Smartphone / PDA Talk Smartphone / PDA Talk

Mobiledia Community

The Lounge The Lounge
News Headlines News Headlines
The Rules The Rules
Meet the Team Meet the Team
Forum Archive Forum Archive


Google
Web Mobiledia.com

©2002-2008 Mobiledia Corp. A Cell Phone Resource Site. All Rights Reserved. Terms of Use | Privacy Policy